Logo - home link Annual Environmental Report      
 

 

 

Table of Contents
Management Commitment
Environmental Protection and Stewardship
Environmental Compliance
Pollution Prevention
Partnerships and Public Involvement
Innovation
A Look to the Future
 
 

NPCA, Sierra Club File Lawsuits Against TVA

The National Parks Conservation Association filed a lawsuit against TVA’s John Sevier and Kingston Fossil Plants in October 2000. The lawsuit charges opacity violations at both plants. (“Opacity” is the term used to describe the density and makeup of the plume or emission cloud coming from a plant’s stacks.)

Both of these plants have fully complied with the permits issued them by the State of Tennessee and with applicable regulatory requirements. For the time period covered by the lawsuit, the Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation has determined that there have been no violations at either plant. Trial is currently scheduled to commence in September 2001.

In December 2000, the National Parks Conservation Association and the Sierra Club filed two lawsuits against TVA alleging that maintenance projects at TVA’s Bull Run and Colbert Unit 5 fossil plants violated the Clean Air Act. These are the same allegations made by EPA in the administrative order issued to TVA by EPA on November 3, 1999.

EPA argues that TVA has violated the Clean Air Act under the new source review requirements over the last 20 years as it has routinely maintained its power plants. TVA argues that its maintenance practices have always complied with the Clean Air Act. TVA sued EPA in the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals in May 2000. Upon TVA’s request, the Court of Appeals set aside, or stayed, the EPA order in August 2000.

TVA has requested a stay of the two lawsuits until the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals issues its decision on the EPA administrative order. Oral argument in the 11th Circuit proceeding is expected in late spring or early summer, with a decision from the Court in late summer or early fall.

Return to previous page